Saturday, November 2, 2024

Review of The Three-Body Problem by Cixin Liu

This book review was written by Eugene Kernes   

Book can be found in: 
Book Club Event = Book List (03/15/2025)
Series Collection = The Three-Body Problem
Intriguing Connections = 1) What Makes Science A Science?, 2) Once Upon A Future


Watch Short Review

Excerpts

“Then, some of them entered a third stage.  The constant, unceasing struggle sessions injected vivid political images into their consciousness like mercury, until their minds, erected upon knowledge and rationality, collapsed under the assault.  They began to really believe that they were guilty, to see how they had harmed the great cause of the revolution.  They cried, and their repentance was far deeper and more sincere than that of those Monsters and Demons who were not intellectuals.” – Cixin Liu, Chapter 1: The Madness Years, Page 10

 

“”These high-energy particle accelerators raised the amount of energy available for colliding particles by an order of magnitude, to a level never before achieved by the human race.  Yet, with the new equipment, the same particles, the same energy levels, and the same experimental parameters would yield different results.  Not only would the results vary if different accelerators were used, but even with the same accelerator, experiments performed at different times would give different results.  Physicists panicked.  They repeated the ultra-high-energy collision experiments again and again using the same conditions, but every time the result was different, and there seemed to be no pattern.”” – Cixin Liu, Chapter 5: A Game of Pool, Page 60

 

Can the fundamental nature of matter really be lawlessness?  Can the stability and order of the world be but a temporary dynamic equilibrium achieved in a corner of the universe, a short-lived eddy in a chaotic current?” – Cixin Liu, Chapter, Page 61


Review

Is This An Overview?

The world of science is being threatened.  During the Chinese Cultural Revolution, science became antagonistic to political favor.  Ye Wenjie is a scientist who survived the persecution by being politically cautious.  But events conspire to make Ye Wenjie a target of the politicians, only to find sanctuary in an isolated political radio base.  A base which was claimed to be used for military applications.  As scientists were in short supply, Ye Wenjie had the required skills that were needed to maintain, operate, and develop the technology. 

 

Decades later, with persecution of scientists through the Cultural Revolution a harsh but distant memory, science has advanced tremendously.  But science seems again to be under threat, as scientists are dying with an increase in crime against academia and research institutions.  There does not seem to be a political motivation for the acts.  What defines science is also under threat, for the methods of science are failing.  Science depends on replication, that the results of an event will be repeated given the same conditions.  But even with advanced technology of participle colliders, different results occur with the same conditions.

 

Wang Miao is a scientist who is asked to participate in a group from which many of the dead scientists have been associated with.  Through the investigation, Wang Miao comes across a game that the scientists play, called 3 Body.  The game is extremely immersive, with the goal of predicting events.  Within the game, civilizations develop during Stable Eras and fall during Chaotic Eras.  The eras can change quickly, with the world undergoing seemingly random and extreme changes.  How are the events of the Cultural Revolution, the death of scientists decades later, and the 3 Body game related?

 

Caveats?

There is a plethora of science terminology in the book.  Written in a way that blends the science and science fiction which makes it difficult to separate when the science ends and the science fiction begins.  There are sections filled with science terminology, ideas, and people involved.  If a reader has a background in various science fields, the science references can add depth to understanding the situations being presented.  Without the science background, the sections can be difficult and confusing to read.

 


Questions to Consider while Reading the Book

•What is the raison d’etre of the book?  For what purpose did the author write the book?  Why do people read this book?
•What are some limitations of the book?
•To whom would you suggest this book?
•What happened during the Chinese Cultural Revolution?
•How were scientists treated during the Cultural Revolution?
•How did people survive the Cultural Revolution? 
•What is a struggle session?
•Why repent? 
•What are the mental stages?
•What happened to Ye Zhetai and Shao Lin?
•What happened to the four female Red Guards that Ye Wenjie was searching for?
•How did Marxism effect China?
•How did people defend socialism? 
•Who is Ye Wenjie?
•How did Bai Mulin effect Ye Wenjie?
•What did people outside think of what happened inside Radar Peak?
•What actually happened in Radar Peak?
•How did Radar Peak effect the ecosystem around the base?
•How was Ye Wenjie treated at Red Coast I?
•Who is Shi Qiang (Da Shi)?
•What is Wang Miao working on?
•What team (PLA) is General Chang leading, and for what purpose? 
•What is the team’s (PLA) combat zone?  Who are the enemy? 
•How are scientist under attack decades after the Cultural Revolution?
•What is the Frontiers of Science? 
•How does the pool table reflect the situation in science?
•What did the particle colliders show? 
•What does the abbreviation ‘SF’ stand for?
•What do the numbers that Wang Miao sees mean?
•What is a V-Suit? 
•Who is Wei Cheng?
•Who is Shen Yufei?
•Who or what is the Lord spoken of?  What Lord does Shen Yufei asked Buddha to help?
•What advice does Shen Yufei give to Wang Miao? 
•What is the purpose of the game, 3 Body?
•Who are the characters of the game?
•What civilizations are present in the game?  What are the features of people?
•What information does Wang Miao find from the 3 Body game?
•Who is Pan Han? 
•Can the universe flicker? 
•Who are the Adventists and Redemptionists? 
•Who are the Trisolarans?
•What choice do the Trisolarans make?
•What is Judgment Day?
•Who is Mike Evans?
•How can the sun be used?
•How can nanotechnology be used?
•What happens during the last ETO meeting that Wang participated in?
•Who joins the ETO?
•What is Pan-Species Communism? 
•How did The Second Red Coast Base get built?
•What information did the Trisolarans communicate?
•What are the Sophons and what is their purpose? 
•What happens to bugs?


Book Details
Translator:              Ken Liu
Original Language: Mandarin
Translated Into:       English
Publisher:               A Tor Book [Tom Doherty Associates]
Edition ISBN:         9780765397485
Pages to read:          316
Publication:             2017
1st Edition:              2006
Format:                    eBook 

Ratings out of 5:
Readability    5
Content          5
Overall          5