Wednesday, November 6, 2024

Review of The Dark Forest by Cixin Liu

This book review was written by Eugene Kernes   

Book can be found in: 
Series Collection = The Three-Body Problem


Watch Short Review

Excerpts

“By an overwhelming majority, a special session of the United Nations General Assembly passed a resolution declaring Escapism a violation of international law.  In strong language, the resolution condemned the division and turmoil that Escapism has created within human society, and described Escapism as a crime against humanity in the eyes of international law.  The resolution called on member states to enact legislation as soon as possible to put a stop to Escapism.” – Cixin Liu, Chapter: Year 3, Crisis Era, Page 374

 

“It took just an instant for Luo Ji to comprehend the true nature of his status as Wallfacer.  Like Say had said, before the mission was handed down, the ones who would undertake it could not have been consulted.  And once the Wallfacer mission and identity were granted, they could not be refused or abandoned.  This impossibility was not due to any individual’s coercion, but because cold logic, as determined by the project’s very nature, meant that once someone became a Wallfacer, an invisible and impenetrable screen was immediately thrown up between them and ordinary people that made their every action significant.” – Cixin Liu, Chapter: Year 3, Crisis Era, Page 424

 

“The Wallfacers were subject to increasing scrutiny from the community.  Whether they had asked for the role or not, they had been set up in the eyes of the masses as messiah figures.  Accordingly, a Wallfacer cult sprang up.  No matter how many explanations the UN and PDC issued, legends of their supernatural abilities circulated widely and grew increasingly fanciful.  In science fiction movies, they were shown as superheroes, and, in the eyes of many, they were the sole hope for humanity.  This gave the Wallfacers an enormous amount of popular and political capital that guaranteed things would go smoothly when they tapped huge amounts of resources.” – Cixin Liu, Chapter: Year 8, Crisis Era, Page 483


Review

Is This An Overview?

The Trisolarans are heading to Earth, with ill intent towards humankind.  Trisolaran technology is far advanced compared to what humans have, but during the time it would take the Trisolarans to reach Earth, humans have the potential to develop more advanced technology compared to what Trisolarans have.  A potential nullified by Trisolaran sophon technology, that is used to prevent humans from understanding physics, from gaining more knowledge about how reality works.  This limits human technology to developments using knowledge already possessed.  Sophons have another function, to inform the Trisolarans of everything that humans are doing and saying.  The threat posed by the Trisolarans changes human society.  Governments and economies change their priorities, people suffer from psychological turmoil.  Various methods are proposed to handle the threats. 

 

A limit to the sophons, is their inability to know what someone is thinking.  Humans create the Wallfacer Project to take advantage of the secrets people carry in their thoughts.  The Wallfacers are four individuals chosen to think of a plan without explaining to others what the plan is.  Nobody can know what the Wallfacers are actually thinking.  With minor limitations, whatever the Wallfacers want, others have to find a way to obtain what they want.  The Wallfacers come from different backgrounds and begin to think of methods to overcome the Trisolaran threat.  The Wallfacers are treated as saviors of humankind. 

 

While there are those wanting humans to overcome the Trisolaran threat, leading to support for the Wallfacer methods.  There are humans who have allied themselves to the Trisolarans, and want the Trisolarans to succeed.  The Trisolaran human allies find a Wallbreaker for each Wallfacer.  The Wallbreakers’ task is to expose the plan that the Wallfacers have in their thoughts.  Can the Wallfacers find a method to save humanity or will the Wallbreakers succeed in reading the Wallfacers thoughts?

 

Caveats?

This book not only requires readers to have some familiarity with science, but the reader also has to become an investigator.  The reader has to become a Wallbreaker, to continuously try to figure out the Wallfacers plan.  This book is filled with events that appear to have insignificant consequences, obvious consequences, or random behavior, which can have drastic consequences for the future of humanity, and have different reasons and outcomes than expected.  The variety of events can make it difficult to understand how they coalesce, and the variety of perspectives can be difficult to keep track of.

 


Questions to Consider while Reading the Book

•What is the raison d’etre of the book?  For what purpose did the author write the book?  Why do people read this book?
•What are some limitations of the book?
•To whom would you suggest this book?
•What is cosmic sociology?  What are the axioms of cosmic sociology? 
•Is there a difference between thinking and saying?
•What is the difference between how the Trisolarans share thoughts and how humans share thoughts?
•How do the Trisolarans use disguises?
•What is a sophon and what are they capable of?
•What are the options do humans present to handle the Trisolarans?
•What are the Escapism plans?
•What happens to the Escapism plans and who does the outcome benefit?
•Who are the Wallfacers and what do they do?
•How do the Wallfacers carry out their plans?
•How does the world react to the Wallfacers?
•Who is Frederick Tyler?
•Who is Manuel Rey Diaz?
•Who is Bill Hines?
•Who is Keiko Yamasuki?
•Who is Luo Ji?
•Does Luo Ji have a mental health problem when trying to write a love story?
•Who is Shi Qiang (Da Shi)?
•Who is Zhang Beihai? 
•What did General Chang Weisi think of Zhang Beihai?
•How has the spirit of armies changed over time? 
•When will the Trisolarans travel to Earth?
•How big is the Trisolaran Fleet and what happens to it?
•What is the Doomsday Battle?
•What is hibernation and why is it used?
•What weapons are thought to be available in the future? 
•What is the outcome of the ETO?
•What is the Planetary Defense Council (PDC)?
•Why is everyone getting a flue with mild symptoms?
•Can thought be controlled?
•What is the Faith Center?
•What is the defeatist mentality?  How do people respond to defeatism? 
•What does the future look like?  Specifically Crisis Era year 205?
•What is the government structure of Crisis Era year 205?
•What was the Great Ravine?
•Can there be peace talks with the Trisolarans?
•What are human spacecrafts cable of?
•How have humans adapted to space?
•What happens to Luo Ji after hibernation?
•What is Killer 5.2?
•What is a distributed command system and a centralized command system?
•What happens aboard the Natural Selection?
•What is the Trisolaran probe?
•What do humans think about the Trisolaran probe before contact with the probe?
•What was the formation of the human fleet when reaching the probe?
•What happens when the human contact the Trisolaran probe?
•What happened to the Quantum spaceship?
•What happened to Starship Earth?
•What is the Dark Forest?
•What happens to the Earth and Trisolarans?


Book Details
Translator:              Joel Martinsen
Original Language: Mandarin
Translated Into:       English
Publisher:               A Tor Book [Tom Doherty Associates]
Edition ISBN:         9780765397485
Pages to read:          419
Publication:             2017
1st Edition:              2008
Format:                    eBook 

Ratings out of 5:
Readability    5
Content          5
Overall          5